November 22, 2026, 11:03:11 pm
Username:

Password:

Topic: Useless Perks - new Ideas  (Read 6469 times)

Urukhai

  • Posts: 254
    • View Profile
Useless Perks - new Ideas
« on: May 25, 2015, 10:17:22 am »
Hello everyone!

Since we are latelay talking about new weapon perks. I noticed that too many perks are useless and players are focused only on a certain and concrete ammount of them.

So don't be rude, because this is only my opinion. If we do it all together, we may find something we would like to see in the game. I guess that all together we will be able to find the balance and make the game more interseting for us an for new players.

I may have fogotten some useless perks but we can add them later here. If some of them are repeated for x1000 times then we should paste this post and never repeat it again. (we have 50 pages of suckgestions, I don't really want to read 'em  all and you either)



Blessed are the weak => Useless perk, since weakness exists no more
its alternative
Blessed are the dead => Ability to reanimate dead players, if they were not killed by any critical animation and if their HP are not below than -100. Could be interesting to see a medic on the field. A real one. Ofc it should have a certain cooldown depending on your doc skill. Should depend on your inteligence and agility like 6 IN and 8 AG and 150 doc skill

Bonus Move => Requires 6 AG and gives 2 bonus moves during TB
its alternative
Bonus Move => Would require 10 Agility and give 4 bonus move, since this perk could be taken 2 times on 2238. Thus it will have sense to take it in TB and gives no advantages in RT. If you have any propositions, let's talk about it.

Earlier Sequence => Requires 5 PE gives +2 Sequence
its alternative
Earlier Sequence => Requires 7 PE gives +4 Sequence in TB and multiplies AP restoration by 1,25/1,5 (1,5 might be too much)
Well in this case we could have a new build which is not a tank, not a sniper, not a burster but a speed shooter. Some one who would neglect tankyness and  do real DPS. A faster AP restoration for less but continious damage. We can talk about it.

Quick pockets => Inventory costs x2 AP and reloading 1AP
its alternative
Quick pockets => Support Perk ? I rarely saw people using it. Let's talk about it.

Gain ST,PE,EN,EN,IN,AG,LU => +1 Skill point
its alternative
Gain ST,PE,EN,EN,IN,AG,LU => +2 Skill points, could have sense, I doubt someone would spent one perk for this.

Ghost => Additional sneak bonuses if close to objects.
its alternative
Ghost => It became a useless perk. With motion sensor it became even worse. Now we have long range sneakers with LSW which keep a safe distance. What if Ghost would give an additional sneak bonus against the motion sensor? You spot a full sneak with ghost not within 15 hexes but 8 or 10 ? 8 Hexes remains far.

Healer => 2 Separate perks
its alternative
Healer => 60 + 80 Additional Hit points healed. Would have more sense to chose only on perk and not waste 2 perks for it.

Heave Ho! => + 3 and +3 range for throwing weapons. Two perks
its alternative
Heave Ho! => +10 throwing range as only one support perk requiring 150% throwing

Iron Grip and Tree Trunks Thighs => Additional resistances for weapon drops and knockdowns.
its alternative
Iron Limbs => Merged effects of both perks. Could be finally usefull in PvP. I think that leg shooting should be more devastating, do more KDs and cripples even higher chances for running targets. Bear traps should be craftable and used in PvP aswell (maybe mines should be included in game). I doubt there would be any massive abuse since the "light step" support perk could help a lot too. It would make fights more dynamic.

What do you think all about it ?
« Last Edit: May 25, 2015, 11:47:25 am by Urukhai »

Chosen One

  • Posts: 1051
  • Ya. Really Me. Want More Than That, PAY ASSHOLE!
    • View Profile
    • Ten Thousand ManiacsĀ®
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #1 on: May 25, 2015, 10:34:59 am »
I like the idea of Quick Pockets as a support perk.
Could it become a reward for a quest/job? Merchant in Fillintheblank asks you to haul something to somewhere, when you ge th there the receiver says, "Hey wanna see a neat trick?" you puck up quick pockets as a partial reard.
Mika TAN, Nika NOIRE, Traci LORDS, KMart, Sand Nigger
Former Redding Miners Union member.


"Most women watch soaps- I play Fallout."

BACK TO THE FRONT! The Front Lines Are Everywhere...

BB.

  • Posts: 299
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #2 on: May 25, 2015, 11:17:17 am »
Quick pockets as a support perk is a bad idea. Actually making any perk affecting PvP itself a support perk is a really bad idea. And I wouldn't consider quick pockets useless. It's maybe not the best perk, not worth taking for most characters, but definitely it's not weak - there are some builds that can gain huge advantage of it (like RL build).

Bonus Move was nerfed because it was too powerful. Gaining 4 AP in TB is a huge difference as you have to walk there a lot (peek and hide tactic in TB defines winner mostly). So if it was considered as too strong when it was +2/+2 it definitiely would be OP if gave +4.

Earlier sequence - why already have ABx2, so people can get 15 AP easily. 15x1,5 = 22,5 Damn man, really? Sniper would become even more powerful than they are now (currently best build for TC). Game-breaking change.

I like the idea of making Gain perks +2 instead of +1. Could give a reason to take it. But to be honest I don't think a lot builds would win on this (maybe some tank-snipers would consider taking it to have more PE or 1 LK tanks to turn in into 3 - fair number). Still there are far better perks.

Healer - FA is already really strong and balanced as much as possible (there is no point in healing more that 300, because no one has that much HP :D), because in most fights one-time-use. So Medic perk seems to be a better option - still no one really takes it.

+1 for Iron Limbs, but still useless. :D

Blessed are the dead. I personally hate this concept, zombies... ehm... ghouls apocalypse.

Motion sensors already do great job against sneakers. I'm up for nerfing this class properly (currently the idea is good, but something seems not to work as intended - f.e. P90 not giving penalty), not bumping it.

Heave Ho! is a good one, but not as a support perk. The only real use for it would be plasma grenades anyways, so you think it would be a good idea for anyone being able to throw them that far? Second grenade launcher? :/


Problem with many perks is that they are useless on the premise. There are some perks that are just better for PvP so people take them more gladly. On the other hand - bumping these not worth taking could make them an OP way to bump some typical builds (like giving a sniper, who bases on APs, even more boost than currently possible in cost of toughness or other perk he doesn't really need that much).

Mighty

  • Posts: 346
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #3 on: May 25, 2015, 11:32:18 am »
Quote
Blessed are the weak => Useless perk, since weakness exists no more
its alternative
Blessed are the dead => Ability to reanimate dead players, if they were not killed by any critical animation and if their HP are not below than -100. Could be interesting to see a medic on the field. A real one. Ofc it should have a certain cooldown depending on your doc skill. Should depend on your inteligence and agility like 6 IN and 8 AG and 150 doc skill
It is better to add this effect to Medic perk

Quote
Bonus Move => Requires 6 AG and gives 2 bonus moves during TB
its alternative
Bonus Move => Would require 10 Agility and give 4 bonus move, since this perk could be taken 2 times on 2238. Thus it will have sense to take it in TB and gives no advantages in RT. If you have any propositions, let's talk about it.
4ap + 10ap + 2 armor&weaponap +2ap jet = 18 ap  :o 1hexers abuse  :o

Quote
Quick pockets => Inventory costs x2 AP and reloading 1AP
its alternative
Quick pockets => Support Perk ? I rarely saw people using it. Let's talk about it.
No, its usefull perk

Quote
Gain ST,PE,EN,EN,IN,AG,LU => +1 Skill point
its alternative
Gain ST,PE,EN,EN,IN,AG,LU => +2 Skill points, could have sense, I doubt someone would spent one perk for this.
I was already suggest it in last session
has been rejected

Quote
Healer => 2 Separate perks
its alternative
Ghost => 60 + 80 Additional Hit points healed. Would have more sense to chose only on perk and not waste 2 perks for it.
This perks definitely must unite
it would be nice to see this perk lowered healing rate cd, and increased healing rate

Quote
Heave Ho! => + 3 and +3 range for throwing weapons. Two perks
its alternative
Heave Ho! => +10 throwing range as only one support perk requiring 150% throwing

"This perks definitely must unite"

Quote
Iron Grip and Tree Trunks Thighs => Additional resistances for weapon drops and knockdowns.
its alternative
Iron Limbs => Merged effects of both perks. Could be finally usefull in PvP. I think that leg shooting should be more devastating, do more KDs and cripples even higher chances for running targets. Bear traps should be craftable and used in PvP aswell (maybe mines should be included in game). I doubt there would be any massive abuse since the "light step" support perk could help a lot too. It would make fights more dynamic.
No
Already no one shoots at the hands and legs

Mad Matt

  • Posts: 1792
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #4 on: May 26, 2015, 11:40:56 am »
Eariler sequence +1 but only when gives 1,1 ap rest., max 1,25. 1,5 would be really too much.

Making Quick Pockets a Support Perk +1 from me, it's rarelly used. Even if it's gonna give some advantage in PvP it's gonna add it to any one cause it's Support Perk, not taking Normal Perk place 1 from 8 available.

Blessed +1, medic chars would have more advantage than now.

And big fat +1 from me to make bear traps craftable, even mines could be craftable but requier some nice ammount of HQ materials.

Gain +2 in SPECIAL is quiet controversial, but otherwise +1 isn't good too.
Hard to say what would be done about it.

Against other changes Im not +1 either -1, so I don't comment about it.
GUN FOR HIRE


Gooseberry

  • Posts: 126
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #5 on: May 29, 2015, 08:56:52 pm »
Suggestion on quick pockets:

-1 ap when performing general actions. Using doctor, repair, stimms, gathering etc.
Ap to reload set to 1 (like it currently does).

Makes the perk a more interresting for crafters and pvpers.

Mad Matt

  • Posts: 1792
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #6 on: May 29, 2015, 09:28:40 pm »
adn -1 for changing equip
GUN FOR HIRE


General Devon Oliver

  • Supporter
  • Posts: 451
  • For Valor!!!
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #7 on: June 06, 2015, 06:58:25 pm »
I like it 1+
Merc For Hire, Universal Player

Ion Cannon

  • Posts: 86
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #8 on: June 06, 2015, 07:17:54 pm »
I like that thread, because it's not one of those "nerf dat, buff it"...
Let's go:

Bonus move is fine as it is for TB, for RT it could give 10% more running speed.

Earlier Sequence is just a no go perk, any other perk at this level is better, so I have no idea how even the buffed version would be worth taking.

Quick pockets is a great perk for a gatling/avenger/bazooka/flamer/grenade launcher or any other weapon which needs reloads regularly. I don't think it needs any changes.

Gains XX perks - those changed would be good, even great, suprassing the implants, need to be discussed.

Ghost - agree

Healer - more than 50 hp could be too much, it could cut the cooldown 1/3 for doc/fa or both

HH - fully agreed

Iron Limbs - agreed.

Actually those would be competetive perks to the toughness/brds/lifegivers.



Mad Matt

  • Posts: 1792
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #9 on: June 06, 2015, 08:24:48 pm »
As I know quick pockets work only in TB with it's lowered AP cost for reloading. So I don't think so, it's must be for any build. It's available at 6 lvl, and there are more valuable perks I think.
GUN FOR HIRE


Ion Cannon

  • Posts: 86
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #10 on: June 06, 2015, 08:26:50 pm »
As I know quick pockets work only in TB with it's lowered AP cost for reloading. So I don't think so, it's must be for any build. It's available at 6 lvl, and there are more valuable perks I think.
cut's reload from 3 ap to 1, that's quite much for grenade launcher and rocket launcher.

Mad Matt

  • Posts: 1792
    • View Profile
Re: Useless Perks - new Ideas
« Reply #11 on: June 06, 2015, 08:50:54 pm »
I didn't know thats working like that in RT, I tought its helping only in TB. Thx.
GUN FOR HIRE