Whats so bad with one hexing somebody or the other stuff you said? It happens all the time. You can get one hit killed regardless the combat mode. If youre too afraid of the "abuse", the first attack from player outside the combat could be ignored in cases where there is a battle already going on.
You could only wait frozen and watch death coming. Second part is lame. Fonline is a kind of game where good reflex and quick, smart thinking do your game, not a kind of where you say "hey, I want to join a fight, could I?" (if you want a chess-like fight you choose SF area, not Redding).
In other words, playercount doesnt have to change at all in the end.
It would. I've already told you (it's only estimated by myself, but 100% true at the same time) - 90% of players prefer RT over TB. I love TB, but I have to admit the game would be dead without quick RT fights. We (PvP players) want good action, not a poker game in Fonline world.
To conclude - it won't work here. If you don't like Real Time you need to find another game (like XCOM etc.) because here, in the multiplayer Fonine world, it's the main part of the game.
Just Fonline or Fonline:Reloaded?
Of the base code used in every Fo server, I guess.