Since the wipe will come sooner or later, I'm throwing out some suggestions.
Feel free to discuss and suggest post-wipe changes.
This is not a "I want more dungeons" topic,
but for brainstorming about improvements of certain parts of the game that have been problematic.
Thus your suggestions should be explained properly even if you're just throwing out a rough idea.
----
There has been quite some discussion about followers (slaves, mercs and companions)
Personally, 2 out of my 3 main characters can have 2 companions (3 after I hit 300 speech).
I like the idea of a leader build, but also agree that they are too much of an advantage.
Also I think that companions should rather be actual players than npcs.
So, I suggest to remove companions, leaving players with mercenaries.
Slaves should be unable to fight, as was suggested many times.
There also should be charisma requirements for having followers
and maybe charisma/speech based perks that improve mercs.
That way you could still play leader builds but they would have handicaps towards full combat builds.
Likewise it should not be easy to get as many followers with just speech, 1 CHA and drugs.
A possible option would be to make merc prices dependent on Charisma, Speech and Barter (and Perks).
Leaders would pay little while non-leaders would pay huge sums.
Mercs absolutely can't be transfered from one player to the other in this case though.
---
Crafting and farming is too easy in my opinion.
Private mines should be removed and public mines should require a fee (100 caps or something like that).
That would make botting harder and on one hand prevent inflation of crafting materials but on the other hand make it easier for new players to earn caps from experienced players by selling raw materials.
You are probably thinking that this would make crafting a chore, BUT that is only due to crafting bonuses which require you to craft a huge amount of items.
Crafting bonuses are not only too powerful but were also responsible for several problems with the combat mechanics.
My suggestion to prevent these problems AND the need to craft insane amounts of items
is to remove crafting bonuses and instead give weapons several upgrade options.
For example:
You could attach a scope to an assault rifle for longer range
or an extended magazine for higher ammunition capacity
or a champer modification to fire higher calibre ammunition etc etc ...
Some of these upgrades should be craftable while others could be found in the wasteland.
I can offer to create the images for these upgrade-versions of existing weapons and armors.
---
Rare items should really be rare and not lie around in caves or lockers.
I think it would be more interesting if they were lootable from powerful encounters or special encounters.
Hunting lockers is so easy it's boring and caves are just really annoying (and abusable due to things like the "easier cave hunting" tool).
Some items should only be available through quests/dungeons (high end weapons / armor) while others should only be available in events (implants).
This could also give npc factions some use, for example by making a brotherhood quest chain, consiting of several quests that require you to have a certain level and reward you with brotherhood armor on level 20, power armor on level 30 and hardened power armor on level 40.
Only once per character and they should not be too easy to prevent farming / exploits.
Maybe they should even require you to play in a group.
There should be more simple pvp events like 1vs1 or 5vs5 championships.
Probably not as hard to do as it might seem since you only need a map and a GM for this.
This would probably be the best way to aquire top tier stuff like implants.
They could be additional to GM auctions or GM auctions could be for different things.
---
Make reputation count again and be un-resetable.
People complain about thieves and player killers and this is the one drawback that stands against all the advantages that lie in shooting first and just being a ruthless bastard.
Player killing and thieving are part of the "wasteland is harsh" schtick, but there should be at least some negative repurcussions.
Positive reputation should be worked for and negative rep should be easy to get and hard to lose.
This one would not actually be that hard, just remove rep reset and make certain factions appear more randomely on the worldmap.
Having a negative rep with the brotherhood has no risk if you can meet them only around their HQ
but if you can meet them anywhere (even if rarely) having negative rep with them would actually be a big thing.
Equally thieves would have to actively keep their rep up if they don't want to get killed by people on the spot all the time.
---
Reward players for improving the game.
Some players started making maps and I think finished ones would be worth a neat reward.
Just as an incentive so they actually finish their projects except losing interest due to little to no feedback.
---
Well, that's it for the moment.