I have tried SF carvan alone on my fighting crafter 3 times.
1) stopped in 2/3 way when I runned out of ammo (3k) and ss (20)
2) stopped in 1/2 way - caravan driver died on ghouls (hard to kill them fast enough and driver is dumb enough to stand near those white ones

)
3) stopped in 1/2 way - caravan driver died on robots
Also once Reno - NCR
I took some Bandits in CA for Bounty Hunters so I didn't shot them just some other npc then I notced half of my caravan was dead

Killed them all but caravan driver was dead.
I didn't die single time because DMG of enemies vs player (that can think and react better than npc) is not the problem (ok, robots were a bit difficult but next time with tesla helmet it was ok).
The problem is HP and healing of some mobs. Just like in some of pve events, it's not fun shoting npc that can't kill you for 1-2 minutes bursting insane ammount of ammo to get his hudge HP to 0.