The crafting bonus system is not a bad idea per se,
but it causes one major problem ...
Items without bonus become worthless. Or let's say easily disposable.
It doesn't matter if you lose your no-bonus combat armor and gatling.
This encourages PvP (which can be good or bad), but more importantly
it hurts player trade, since items are worth much less.
I want to suggest two things.
1) Make bonuses less good
-1AP is a huge thing, even more so than +5 crit chance.
In my opinion it's necessary to cap all attacks at 2AP and make -1AP rarer.
This could make Fast Shot less beneficial though, so I think it needs another bonus.
Maybe ignore 10% armor crit chance mod. Maybe another +5 damage. I dunno.
Maybe -1AP should only be possible on unique items.
+SPECIAL is another huge thing. And doesn't even make much sense.
I can imagine my shiny new metal armor mk2 to give a bonus to charisma
but why a leather jacket would increase my intelligence and carry weight, I do not understand.
It might be better to limit attribute bonuses strictly to implants, since they will become more common soon anyways.
Other bonuses should be fine as long as they don't go overboard.
Accuracy is a great bonus and +min/max damage isn't bad either.
Crit power and even more so crit chance can be huge.
Maybe they should only increase by 1 per bonus slot but be stackable.
Meaning that only a unique weapon could have +5 crit chance for example.
2) Make crafting harder
I really like what I read about the farming and crafting on the TLA Mk2 wiki.
Items require more materials and farming is more complex. You need a crowbar
to pry metal parts and junk from actual scenery items such as car wrecks or vending machines, for example.
I think this is a great idea and would add a nice scavenger feel to the game and give items like crowbars more use.
As for the more materials part ...
If an item is easy to craft it loses value. Why buy something that can be farmed and crafted in a few minutes?
If an item is hard to craft players can ask better prices for them and player trade would increase.
This would be very healthy for player-to-player interaction and also the community.
Opinions?