There's a 50% chance to get at least one bonus, and this gives crafting and the weapons and armors themselves a flavor they wouldn't have otherwise. True, 1 out of 10 weapons is probably pretty on par for an Advanced or Unique weapons with 3-4 bonuses, but that doesn't mean the other 9 guns are valueless. Now, if there was a way to up the selling price of weapons with such affixed to them, that would be wonderful. Currently aside from literal loadout bonuses the game doesn't distinguish unique items versus the vanilla versions in such situations.
Dustin, you missed biggest thing with Stats.
All crafted weapons may get bonuses, which leads to situation, where best crafted weapon is in highest demand. Means, that to get speciffic ammount of certain bonuses, you need to craft certain number of this weapon. Its not a problem for me, if those bonuses would be rare as hell and skill dependant/perks on crafter, but then playerbase would say that "its to hard to get a bonus". So, we end up with FLOOD of weapons and resources to craft them. If you think that in Post-Apo world crafting daily over 250 shotguns is okay, I say "hell no!".
So, reasuming I am right and I am wrong, both options are bad: if there is a stat on weapon, it obsolete one without that stats. If player demand upgraded weapon, they need less weapon without stats. If there are weapons that are needless, and weapons that are heavly demanded, player will tend to farm/craft weapon of best choice, thus will always WANT (rant to Kilgore too) to get those things easier. The thing is, that due mechanics that allows you to gain stat, we have milions of guns.
I remember having over 300 shotguns in one day, when I wanted to do around 10-20 uniques... just for fun and out of boredoom.
As thing goes for money - Fallout had uniqu system that generated feel, that you are on wasteland, you dire to get resources. And FOnline REloaded give you more resources you could imagine, and plus it gives you crafting - yet, it is not crafting as band aid (as it should be), but 24/7 manufacturing everything for yorself. So you dont need to group, and actually you dont need anyhing from anyone, and it makes caps almost useless (I barely spend 10k in 2 months of gameplay to any trade...). After few weeks, you discover its another FARMVILLE and you dont neet to play this game, because you still are alone and has ton of shit you have no use off.
I loged to my base. I see 14 lockers filled with stuff I could hand to around 30 players, from head to toe they would be geared up like mad. I also have over 2,5mil, 5 cars ad resources to build up even more cash. And I never used any autoclick, bot or whats is called, and played around 2-3 hours daily. Since I played alone, I dont have group, so I can not do PVP, unless I have to (which will be fast and boring, since I die alone vs 2-3 players), and there is no adventage of teaming (XP is divided, making otherwise can not be true due multilog system - we have wheel here).
So, yes, I see there need to be changes and most of them are acces to resources and making traders in town (and bartering with them) much more valuable then it is now. They are junk dispansers and capscows.