Kelin, dude, let's talk about this in mumble, not here. PKing is also PvP activity, maybe not so "fair" but it's also a part of PvP. When someone shot you (it doesnt matter, guarded town or not, mine or dungeon) it's not just "mining" or "farming"anymore, it becomes a pvp activity, i dont really understand whats the point of this discussion, this particular situation is clear. You can take a look at screens again, and try to think, what are you talking about right now. It's clear that he did wrong.