After the wipe I was discouraged from coming back. Unlike many of you hardcore players it's hard for me to justify the many hours it takes to get established in this game only for it to disappear every few months. After my brother started playing again 2 months ago, however, I decided to start up again about a month ago.
After diligently leveling my character to about level 45 I noticed my 260 energy weapons skill was no longer reducing my durability loss on my weapons from shooting contrary to what the wiki says. After some digging I found cryptic notes on the change in a change log, then further searched the forums to find 1 or 2 confirming comments from Kilgore (a horrible experience for trying to find important information relative to using the wiki, but that's a separate problem).
After discovering this information a few nights ago I've lost all will to continue playing the game (which is a shame because I was really enjoying it). If the goal was to encourage more casual gamers to pick this game up I know this change is encouraging the opposite for me. With the removal of the possibility to realistically mitigate durability loss we've also lost the ability to casually enjoy the end game. In the 2 months since my brother, father and I have been playing this league (for example) we've found exactly 1 solar scorcher, 3 alien blasters and 0 other high end energy weapons. If I were to take any of these weapons out and use them they would be broken beyond repair (or simply explode from critical failures) by the end of the play session.
For uncraftable weapons such as these the only hope a causal player like myself has for consistently using such weapons is to invest heavily in our characters over time to the point that we earned such rewards as reduced durability loss. With drop rates as abysmal (or outright gated as is the case with power armour etc) as they are the only realistic weapons I can hope to use consistently are the ones that I'm able to craft and with the best half dozen or so weapons in the energy weapon group all being uncraftable I'm forced into 1 of either 2 scenarios:
1. No-life this game (8+ hours daily) to the point I have the caps to buy enough low durability found weapons of other players using the forum to fuel a couple hours worth of shooting a night.
2. Pick another game to play because being a second class citizen isn't fun.
Hardcore gamers Kilgore is balancing around will all be picking option #1. They are likely unfazed by this change and to this day run around with the biggest baddest weapons this game has to offer. The only people this change really hurts are those causal gamers like me, who try to build their wealth over time (losing what they have when they died, which is fair) until they can reap the rewards they've earned.
In it's current state (unlike before the wipe) I find this game unplayable. Most forum goers will likely take the elitist view on this, like most of your hardcore player base, to the tune of "fuck you, you won't be missed" and I expect that knowing the community but forum goers do not represent the entire player base. All I can say is that changing things like this in a ham fisted way to deal with your "1%" players will only continue to alienate new or causal players until hardcore elitists are all you have left, and preventing new players from ever getting the chance to love your game. It will slowly stagnate your game into oblivion. Thats not something I want, we've got a cool game going here, but the decision to exclude all but the most die-hard ultimately comes down to Kilgore and the like.
Maybe if your top players are running around with that same turbo plasma for 3 months it means we aren't challenging them enough. Maybe try to find a way to encourage some pvp, or tough pve instead of making it impossible for anyone to keep their hard earned gear. Alternatively, give us some reliable ways to obtain these hard to get items in good condition in a self found, soloable way to give us causal players with no pro friends some hope to compete.
I've never seen another player use a solar scorcher for example, and as a player who made a character specifically to use one I'd love to be one myself (even if it takes lots of dedication). That kind of diversity is cool. Everyone running around with plasma pistols because "that's what you can make" is much less cool and even outright boring. What a waste to have all this cool content only 1% of the player-base can experience for more than 5 minutes.
I can hear the responses already: "Just another noob who wants to have 10 Power Armors or Advanced Power Armors in their base". Please don't assume I'm some entitled noob. Remember that the truth is like a sculpture: You cannot gain full understanding from a single perspective. Weather or not you, in the end, deem my input actionable do understand that for whatever underlying reason I am feeling the way I am feeling (as a matter of fact) regardless of how you or hardcore players feel from the same change. So this input is valuable to you, even if it contradicts how you feel about the same change, because the end result is players feeling this way. Also, for every player like me who brings stuff like this to your attention, there are 10 (including my brother and father) who feel the same but don't tell you so it would be short sighted to dismiss it as a 1 off.
Anyway, the core of the issue is that losing weapons through no fault of your own is a frustrating experience. People do not like frustration, and its not fun. People feel frustration when something wrong happens with something they care about that they have no control over. So when people invest in their characters as much as they can, put in the time to find rare weapons (which is good, they should be hard to get!) and then loose those weapons to no fault of their own then you've taken the control they have over the situation (unlike building characters or finding loot) and bred that frustration.
If I have a rare weapon that I've earned, and I loose it because of a decision I've made then that's something I have to live with. If i bite off more than I can chew in a fight, that's my fault. If I've farmed in a dangerous area, my fault. If I've chosen low luck SPECIAL and had my weapon explode because it was below 50%, that's my fault. All those involved decisions I've made knowing the potential consequences with options to mitigate them at a cost. Using my weapon to fire is not a choice. In order to play this game I must shoot my weapon out of necessity. It's not a choice. So loosing a weapon simply from using it doesn't involve any risk / reward. It's boring and frustrating because there is no option for a player to mitigate it reasonably. (yea, i know about oil cans but at the rate of durability loss even at the highest skill level its unrealistic to use oil cans to sustain because of their rarity).
Armours are different! You lose durability from being shot. Being shot is something I have control over. I can line-of-sight enemies, or pick off the right 1s before they get in range. I don't even necessarily take hits during each fight. For weapons, I cannot be in a fight without shooting. The equivalent situation for armours would be if I lose durability for simply wearing them. Like moving or something makes it lose durability. That, like shooting, is out of the players control and leads to situations where you might find a player with 10 in his stash because using it is a guarantee you will lose it no matter what you do.
TLDR:So the problem, in a nutshell, is that losing items you've earned through no fault of your own is frustrating (ie not fun). On the other side of the coin, this change was implemented because people running around with rare stuff all the time is also not fun because you lose the novelty of rare items. The admin's perspective is that of a hardcore player. You see the best of the best players and the metrics of how they use these items. You see the guy with 10 power armours and say "thats too extreme" but what you've done is counter an extreme with another extreme. You've killed a fly (representing the small amount of top players) with a nuke (effecting the entire player base).
There are many ways to counter this frustration than the way you've used. Maybe:
- You could change the formula to 301 - skill so that even at max skill there is still some durability loss while still rewarding the character investment
- You could reduce the overall durability loss for weapons to 1/5 or 1/10 of it's current rate at 200 to make the loss less extreme (because right now it IS extreme even on the top end)
- You could change the formula to not lose durability on every shot (maybe only crit failures?) to still punish those with low luck without punishing everyone so theres risk and rewards to choosing low luck (making durability loss your own fault again)
- You could make random encounters gradually tougher until the player is screwed if they keep rare weapons on them for long periods. At least they'd feel less cheated if they died using it instead of just basically having it stolen from them for simply playing.
- You could make oil cans craftable, so we have a (probably expensive) way to reliably maintain important weapons
- You could make rare weapons more common and spawn in better condition (probably my least favorite fix for the same reasons you implemented this change in the 1st place)
- You could make special vendors with these items for sale reliably at exorbitant prices
- You could make perfect repairs increase max durability, successful keep the max durability the same and only decrease on failure with a boost of perfect repairs on the Mr. Fixit perk
Just a few ideas, but all of them much fairer than simply destroying people hard earned rewards simply for enjoying them. The root cause of my problem is that having no control is frustrating. Giving us some way to realistically solo using rare weapons without taking them from us unfairly would bring back the fun for me. Hopefully you take this constructive criticism to heart. Cheers!