Crafting in Reloaded is a very, VERY straightforward system. You gather some items from a mine or random encounter, you head to a workbench with said items, and done, you have yourself a nice pretty new weapon. For those that one weapon doesn't cutting, there is grinding. Is it a bad thing?
(Would like to remind you all that this is not a rant, let me get to the point)
Not at all, grinding is a part of the game, and actually means just putting lots of your time to focus on the creation of one or two things only. For example, let's grind buffout.
>First, you need meat jerky, lot's of it, as 1 buffout requires 4 meat jerkies.
>Each meat jerky requires two pieces of meat.
>Meat is gathered on chunks of 5 by using knife on butchery table.
Once you have a decent amounts of meat jerky, you need two chemical components for each buffout, and for that we head to Waterworks to spam those barrels with that magical powder. Alright, we have a great amount of both meat jerky and chemical components, let's craft them.
Turns out you can't craft buffout, as you require the recipe. Time to head to Reno most dangerous area to buy a blueprint for 7500 caps. Once we did that (not without dying in a horrendous way before), we need to find a medical terminal first. Nooo, you forgot about the profession didn't you?
Turns out you had 100% doc after all, and all you had to do was to head to Junktown, NCR, Redding, San Francisco or Vault City, talk with the doctors and receive an intense learning course for 4500 caps overall.
And then, finally, after all the running around, you manage to gather your crafted meat jerky, the collected chemical components, and head to a medical terminal in San francisco most probably.
Congratulations, you have crafted 50 buffouts!
After that insane journey, you have managed to create 50 buffouts, and that, my friends, is a beautiful thing. Buffout, mostly a PvP used drug, requires a good amount of time to be crafted, as the steps above show. If you don't have money for an outpost, you head to Modoc (An open PvP area), you make meat jerky, then head to Waterwork (An abandoned but still open PvP area) and then finally head to San Francisco to make them.
Thanks to the hard and pretty extensive task of crafting buffouts, a player just crossed 3 unpopular locations not to do PvP, but to do a task that he set himself to do, which was the making of a PvP drug, ironically.
Just like mutant GR quest, buffout is the mutant quest of the crafting system, it's unique, forces you to walk around the world, even in dangerous areas, in order to make it. And that is one of the Many steps that reloaded need to do in order to make the world feel alive, make crafting be a chain of events that move the player out of the typical MINE > WORKBENCH line.
I've met many players whose sole purpose was to grind certain items, and I keep hearing "I just crafted 1000 super stims". This players are no longer in the game until wipe, as wipe is the only thing that means a radical change in the routine that Reloaded has become to some players.
Suggestion?
The essence of a new crafting system would be to make the player move around the world. Does that mean the player will have to head to very dangerous locations? No, thanks to the militia system, even TC area cities are like NCR, guarded but dangerous nevertheless.
Remove meat table from bases, add it on locations like Vault City and NCR. Make fibers grow only in Klamath, and empty hypodermics to be sold in Den. Make Gecko a, well, geckos hunting place. Make the best doctors be in SF or Gecko to aquire level 2 profession, and the decent doctors to teach only lvl 1. Add a quest that requires you to bring something to convince them to teach you. Same could go for armor crafting, weapon crafting and what not.
The simplicity of the system is what makes crafting players to be bored to death, as it's so simple it forces them to fall into routine, while an extended crafting system would put them on a chain of tasks that force them to walk around, meet other players, and complete quests.