FOnline: Reloaded

General => General Game Discussion => Topic started by: Martyr on September 01, 2013, 04:43:35 am

Title: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 01, 2013, 04:43:35 am
I registered my first character when there were 300 people online, and the towns were swarming with players.

Now 8 hours later, I realized that I have not encountered a single player outside of a town.

What gives?
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: S.T.A.L.K.E.R on September 01, 2013, 05:15:03 am
Maybe everyone has outdoors and avoiding each other? :P
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 01, 2013, 05:44:26 am
Maybe everyone has outdoors and avoiding each other? :P

Never even been given the option to encounter or avoid another player, and I'm certain that if it was possible I'd have been PK'd by now.

No, don't think that's it.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Desert Mutt on September 01, 2013, 11:16:00 pm
Same here. Been playing since yesterday encountered 0 players, even tried to camp for people, no luck.
 WTF?
Encountering players and being PKed is a huge part of the FOnline, without this feature is see no difference between this and Hello Kitty.  >:(
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: S.T.A.L.K.E.R on September 02, 2013, 12:46:00 am
After playing for 2 days, he's right, I have not encountered any other player.

Only message says that someone is in your zone. But you never see him.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Desert Mutt on September 02, 2013, 01:41:34 am
I wonder if that has something to do with 'hybrid' approach for PvE & PvP that was discussed in some other thread.  ::)

Bring open PvP back into the wastelands.  >:(
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: apocalypseman on September 02, 2013, 03:19:31 am
I noticed this as well.

When resources are easily gathered and are abundant, I don't mind for some early pvp.

Unlike FOnline2, where collecting materials is a major pain in the ass and if you are killed it would set you back quite a bit of time.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: SporePlants on September 02, 2013, 04:36:09 am
Can we get an admin response on this?
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 02, 2013, 04:40:39 am
I talked to Kilgore on IRC about this earlier.

It seems there is a low-level encounter protection feature that is either bugged, not fully finished, or on it's own program and not playing nice.

He indicated that it would be fixed once the scripter who has been working with the Worldmap scripts is able to work on it.

Other than that, no other information was given.  I also didn't ask.

NOTE: The above is a representation of my personal recollection only, and should not be taken as 100% accurate or factual. 
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: DocAN on September 02, 2013, 05:18:51 am
There is low lvl protection feature.

Pls describe at what lvl You are and in witch zones something happend.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: RedneckRage on September 02, 2013, 08:01:01 am
I'm lvl 11 and had no player encounter yet. On the other hand, some lower lvl friends had encounters already.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Kilgore on September 02, 2013, 08:13:39 am
This will be adjusted today.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Desert Mutt on September 02, 2013, 09:38:02 pm
What is considered low level?
How does that protection work?
I'm level 19 and couldn't encounter anybody.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Kilgore on September 02, 2013, 09:40:27 pm
Now it should work fully.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Desert Mutt on September 02, 2013, 11:20:27 pm
How should it work? what is the mechanics of this feature?

IMHO it should be removed completely as it promotes ALTing.

It can be abused for creating:
- unencounterable miner alts
- unencounterable scavanger alt
- unencounterable taxi alt

Make 10 int skilled char, tag outdoorsmen get few levels and you have an alt for safe travel and so on.
That will make wasteland encounters more rare and only PvP that will be happening is TC if there wont be exodus of PvP oriented players from the server (due to this feature).
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Perteks on September 03, 2013, 06:31:22 am
I think highest level in party decide about encountering other players
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 03, 2013, 08:28:36 am
Must be totally disabled then.

My 0XP level 1 alt encountered someone walking to town from the spawn point.

What is the level where you should begin to encounter other players, and vice versa?
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: apocalypseman on September 03, 2013, 08:53:43 am
I encountered someone, although this person was greened. We were both about 6th level or higher. I got which zone.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Kilgore on September 03, 2013, 11:43:44 am
Must be totally disabled then.

My 0XP level 1 alt encountered someone walking to town from the spawn point.

What is the level where you should begin to encounter other players, and vice versa?

It is disabled currently. Check the latest changelog.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: wladimiiir on September 03, 2013, 01:26:21 pm
Personally for me it is frustrating to get killed by players in encounters even if I am experienced. I have no intention for PvP, I just want to gather some resources, craft, sell it, etc., maybe do some PvE and I bet there are more people like me out there. My suggestion would be to have option to "turn off" possibility to encounter other players and to be encountered by other players. This option would be up to every player, how he would want to have it set. As a downfall for this, e.g. you would not be able to send distress on encounter, or there would be more frequent "encounter mobs" for the player.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Knife_cz on September 03, 2013, 01:29:05 pm
Personally for me it is frustrating to get killed by players in encounters even if I am experienced. I have no intention for PvP, I just want to gather some resources, craft, sell it, etc., maybe do some PvE and I bet there are more people like me out there. My suggestion would be to have option to "turn off" possibility to encounter other players and to be encountered by other players. This option would be up to every player, how he would want to have it set. As a downfall for this, e.g. you would not be able to send distress on encounter, or there would be more frequent "encounter mobs" for the player.
Well then.
What is the purpose of playing FOnline?
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: wladimiiir on September 03, 2013, 01:33:40 pm
What is the purpose of playing any game?
For me it is to have fun. And if fun is gathering or crafting and no fun is getting killed every time I go to an encounter...why not to have such possibility in game via some option?
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Knife_cz on September 03, 2013, 02:01:38 pm
What is the purpose of playing any game?
For me it is to have fun. And if fun is gathering or crafting and no fun is getting killed every time I go to an encounter...why not to have such possibility in game via some option?
You can play Fallout 1/2/3/NV if you don't want players to encounter. And that is a fact.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: wladimiiir on September 03, 2013, 02:08:05 pm
Thank you. That is great idea!!! How come I didn't think of it myself? ???

I have no idea why you are trying to "over-argue" me. I shared my point of view and I really don't care if it makes into the game or not. I don't think it will somehow affect your gameplay if it would be implemented anyway.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: baskila on September 03, 2013, 02:12:56 pm
What is the purpose of playing any game?
For me it is to have fun. And if fun is gathering or crafting and no fun is getting killed every time I go to an encounter...why not to have such possibility in game via some option?
You can play Fallout 1/2/3/NV if you don't want players to encounter. And that is a fact.
Reloaded is not Counter Strike. Here you can craft, do quests, explore, etc. so as you can see it's not only a pure pvp team death match.
If you want to do only pure PvP go somewhere else, there are others Fonline mods. Don't try to limit others only because you don't like something.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Knife_cz on September 03, 2013, 02:48:54 pm
What is the purpose of playing any game?
For me it is to have fun. And if fun is gathering or crafting and no fun is getting killed every time I go to an encounter...why not to have such possibility in game via some option?
You can play Fallout 1/2/3/NV if you don't want players to encounter. And that is a fact.
Reloaded is not Counter Strike. Here you can craft, do quests, explore, etc. so as you can see it's not only a pure pvp team death match.
If you want to do only pure PvP go somewhere else, there are others Fonline mods. Don't try to limit others only because you don't like something.
When did I ever said I want to do pure PvP? Stop twisting shit. All I am saying that encountering players - in towns, in encounters is part of this game, if you do not want any players to interfere then I once again don't see a reason for you to play, since you can basically do quests/encounters and exploring in Fallout 1/2
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: baskila on September 03, 2013, 03:00:55 pm
Chill out man, no need for cursing. It's not about either having player encounters or not having them at all. It's about meeting low levels only which is part of low level player protection that's all. And such protection should be there. In that form or other.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: DocAN on September 03, 2013, 04:56:58 pm
Work In Progress
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 03, 2013, 05:02:11 pm
I hope this doesn't turn into a PK thread, those derail quickly.

I'd be cool with not being able to encounter low level players or be encountered at low level, or having the ability to turn it on/off, or even a nub island somewhere out in the middle of the ocean on the part of the map we never see.

TLA2 does something similar, and it doesn't seem to affect the game negatively too much.

However it's important to remember that dungeons and other public locations still put all players at risk. NPC mobs are plenty dangerous to new players (not new alts of old players). It's still full loot.

Low level protection isn't going to break my game, I doubt it will break anyone else's.

Besides, if it helps grow the community I'm all for it. The new player retention in these games sucks, in part (not all) because of some of the players in the community.

You can still say "Go cry moar nub, wasteland is harsh", but that just proves the point.

Don't care if you agree with me, it's just a personal opinion born of years of being a PK.

I'm simply curious what the solution will be.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: apocalypseman on September 03, 2013, 05:55:06 pm
You are about to force everyone I know from playing this game to quitting. Once you turned off the low level protection everyone I play with has been pked multiple times.

Many of these players I know who are playing here, quit FOnline 2 because of this. The pking there, in my opinion, got out of hand. Many people left because of that or they rarely play anymore in general.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: CXZ on September 03, 2013, 07:10:09 pm
I hope this doesn't turn into a PK thread, those derail quickly.

I'd be cool with not being able to encounter low level players or be encountered at low level, or having the ability to turn it on/off, or even a nub island somewhere out in the middle of the ocean on the part of the map we never see.

TLA2 does something similar, and it doesn't seem to affect the game negatively too much.

However it's important to remember that dungeons and other public locations still put all players at risk. NPC mobs are plenty dangerous to new players (not new alts of old players). It's still full loot.

Low level protection isn't going to break my game, I doubt it will break anyone else's.

Besides, if it helps grow the community I'm all for it. The new player retention in these games sucks, in part (not all) because of some of the players in the community.

You can still say "Go cry moar nub, wasteland is harsh", but that just proves the point.

Don't care if you agree with me, it's just a personal opinion born of years of being a PK.

I'm simply curious what the solution will be.
i agree at 100% percent but i have no idea what TLA2 is
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 03, 2013, 07:16:02 pm
TLA2 is another FOnline server that was almost entirely Russian, but recently was made English-friendly.

They have a system in place where you're confined to the "low level" area until level 4 I think. It's been a log time since I played it.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: 3.14 on September 03, 2013, 07:49:22 pm
How about this:

chance_to_encounter_player *=5/(5+abs(my_level- encountered_pc_level))

If you don't understand the formula:
-a encounter between a lv1 and a lv 30 player would be about 15% of what is now
-a encounter between a lv5 and a lv 30 player would be about 17% of what is now
-a encounter between a lv10 and a lv 30 player would be about 20% of what is now
-a encounter between a lv15 and a lv 30 player would be about 25% of what is now
-a encounter between a lv20 and a lv 30 player would be about 33% of what is now
-a encounter between a lv25 and a lv 30 player would be about 50% of what is now
-a encounter between a lv30 and a lv 30 player would be about 100% of what is now

It could be caped at lv24 and still produce nice results (with a hyperbolic-like curve).

Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Martyr on September 04, 2013, 12:25:20 am
The basic problem is that you don't need a level 30 character to PK a low level character.

While that would mean level 30's would encounter each other at the regular rate, it also means low level builds would encounter each other at the regular rate.

I can promise you what would happen is people would build low level alts designed specifically to PK.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Desert Mutt on September 04, 2013, 12:35:57 am
I can promise you what would happen is people would build low level alts designed specifically to PK.
+1
 
To minimize butthurt from losing your stuff on low levels what is needed is temporary default tent that u can use on lower levels before you get your own tent (like in FOnline2).
Don't tamper with player encounters please.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Gooseberry on September 04, 2013, 06:15:40 am
While I love stuff like tent raiding, thievery and pvp in general myself.
I do agree that all chars up to a certain level simply shouldn't be possible to encounter.

Perhaps make it impossible to encounter somoene level <6. And after that up until level 10 theres a reduced chance to encounter that lower per levels. In a table this would look as the following:

Level 1: Impossible to encounter anyone
Level 2: Impossible to encounter anyone
Level 3: Impossible to encounter anyone
Level 4: Impossible to encounter anyone
Level 5: Impossible to encounter anyone
Level 6: Impossible to encounter anyone
Level 7: 25% of the normal% to encounter somoene
Level 8: 50% of the normal% to encounter somoene
Level 9: 75% of the normal% to encounter somoene
Level10: 100% Can encounter any other level 10> normally.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Czarny on September 04, 2013, 08:21:03 am
Maybe I miss something, but chance of encounter depends  mostly of your Outdoorsman skill right ?
Give a boost to it for new players, but not depended on level but hours of playing and you get rid of alts problem at the same time.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Castor on November 23, 2013, 03:42:12 pm
Bump.
Same problem. After a week of playing with zero encounters with other players. Me and my friends started test, we concentrated in one sector. Some stayed at the encounters with NPC, another walk around on the map. After a hour we got 0 collisions. We all lvl 20+

Any suggestions?
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: DocAN on November 23, 2013, 03:46:32 pm
You need to change encounter map coz it is getting close after some time - no one will find you no matter what lvl you are
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: Castor on November 23, 2013, 05:25:19 pm
Thx for info, we will try to roam.
Title: Re: Zero Player Encounters - Bug or Feature?
Post by: sogabe on November 24, 2013, 08:56:47 am
? I encounter all the time. Is this an old thread with solved issue?