FOnline: Reloaded

Development => Suggestions => Topic started by: Johnny on April 21, 2015, 07:29:37 pm

Title: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 21, 2015, 07:29:37 pm
Alright so we managed to come up with some ideas for the crit table. Main idea behind this is to end this abuse that last for too long.

Keep in mind that what is proposed here is open for advice its just a suggestion feel free to bring constructive feedback.

So the first thing needed here i believe is to bring back the sniper class as it should be. That need a couple of changes in some perks related to criticals.
Those changes are taken in consideration and need to be updated at the same time as the crit table.

Perks to modify:
-RBTE 50% helmet crit chance and crit power mod.
-Stonewall No longer protects against KO only KD from grenades.
-Man of steel give a -15 crit power mod.

We calculated this with this crit table in the optic that MOS+ bonehead counter Better crit and prevents the nasty 101+ roll as it should be.
It will also render stonewall still useful while not being a must have.
RBTE modifed will make this perk more attractive for snipers.

Old crit table for reference:
Spoiler: show
(http://s9.postimg.org/l5lvwfj9r/2lvhdsy.jpg)

Suggested crit table:
(http://s12.postimg.org/tqd1lru99/reloaded_test2.jpg)

Take in consideration that in the current crit table there is no defense rolls what so ever in the groin for 2 rolls against KO or KD so sometimes you will be knocked down + knocked out resulting in a KO for 15-20ap wich is ridiculous.
In the suggested crit table you cannot be KD + KO

What we are trying to do here is to make the crit table more progressive while not changing it that much.

For unaimed shots the 101+ roll KO has been deleted and replaced by a knock down.

Bypasses roll luck and arent automatic and are have their own separated roll.
KO while still present arent automatic exept for the last roll.

It is kinda obvious also that the weapons that still have crit roll bonus (aka turbo plasma/ plasma), have this bonus removed as well.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table and drugs.
Post by: Corosive on April 21, 2015, 08:08:09 pm
Let's get people talking about this.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Kilgore on April 21, 2015, 09:40:24 pm
Yep, more feedback and discussion is needed.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Rando on April 21, 2015, 10:13:42 pm
I really like the idea of there being more KD's and less KO's, and I especially like no more KO's from unaimed torso shots. God that was the most annoying feeling in the world, being knocked out by a pancor burst or some noob torso shotting with his turbo plasma. Knockouts either needed a severe nerf in where they appear on the crit table, or a severe nerf in how much AP they steal, and this updated one seems to deliver on the former. No doubt in my mind that this crit table is a huge improvement over the current one.
The only thing I might suggest is to make eye crippling a bit easier for snipers, maybe add on an extra -1 point on the perception check on those rolls.

Man of Steel getting a buff is a good idea - as of right now there is no reason to pick it over Stonewall.

With the suggested changes:

Man of Steel: You don't get protection from being juggled by grenade launchers/rockets, but you have a great protection vs aimed shot knockouts, being crippled, etc.

Stonewall: You run a greatly increased risk of being knocked out, but avoid the bullshit from autoknockdown weapons.



An interesting trade off. As of right now Man of Steel basically does nothing because the amount it reduces crit rolls by is meagre in comparison to the bonuses snipers get.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Beer on April 21, 2015, 10:26:57 pm
I think it looks good. More effects at lower crits that get better as you go up but less crazy powerful crits for the best rolls. So instead of getting hit and either having nothing happen at all or get ko kd blind bypass for 200+ DMG, the effects are more spread out.

 I'm no king of game balance but seems like a crit should do something and most effects are missing from lower levels of old table so even when you crit it meant nothing many times. On my 223 sneak all I did was shoot and pray for lucky roll because though I crit a lot usually it did nothing except when I was lucky enough it destroyed them with huge ko bypass in 1 shot and they had no way to stop it then I plink away while they sit there til they die. Would be more fun and active battle if I would kd more to drain their ap/have a little breathing room and blind and get ko if I'm lucky like this table. On my tank it won't be 1 shot and I just get ready to regear because I'm ko and at 100 HP instantly, or get hit for 20 HP crit with no effects and just kill the enemy.

Just my thought since feedback is requested. But you never know how something will be for certain until it is tested.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: KestreL on April 21, 2015, 10:54:03 pm
I'm not very bright when it comes to crit tables. I understand basic criticals and how knockouts work. So maybe I can give a bit of constuctive advice.

First of all I'd like to mention that making perks that put weapon crits at a stable and reliable experience is a bad idea. This encourages people to make builds that can only fight other builds. And right there - you break balance.

Making a weapon that is OP when fighting against no-anti crit/crit power perks will force people to take these perks. And even after taking them the weapon will be put at a balance. And after taking such perks like e.g: Toughness's - crits - anti crit perks. Etc, the charecter will be weak and easily ate by a swarm of people using fire gecko shells. And yeah, I know that there is not much to do without a masive change after wipe to these weapons (Which will probably be done).

I think it's pointless to add perks to charecter to bring balance to curtain weapons. Better to fix the table so that crits are decent without anti crit perks, and crits are quite bad against anti crit perks.

Dunno if that helped. Just make take on the situation.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Corosive on April 21, 2015, 11:04:15 pm
I difinately think that minimum to everything and anything...

Toughness should be pickable at level 3, and should be required for even tougher.

As it is now the level 3 perks available are pretty fucking shitty lol. There are way too many "useless" ones to me and my build/playing style. Adding toughness to the magic (like 2238 had in it's prime) creates many more build possibilities. By the time you get around to be able to pick toughness there are way better perks to take instead.

Toughness and Even Tougher should be basic generic perks at low level. It helps you progress and you'll need it for combat.

------------------------

Critical table should be more progressive
Eye shots/ etc
1.5x minimum
2x
2.5x
3x
3.5

No instant kills or constant knockouts. Replace with knockdowns as a more likely thing, making counter perks more useful.

------------------

Make AC reduce damage not chance to miss, or make it do both. High AC and AC Perks should make you a tank to generic base damage. But weak to armor piercing stuff.

-----------

Buff mid level small guns +2 min damage +2 max damage
Add piercing to 10mm smg

Buff Flamers +2 m/mx

------------

No instant kills if you can pass checks/ AC/ DT crap

Min 2 shots to get killed by a player. Let a critical reduce their HP to 1, instead of death.

Knockdown always happens before a Knockout.

If you get knockdowned too many times in a short span -> Knocked out

Knockouts should be reserved to rare hits, or for people that aren't wearing helmets that can stop the shooters bullet.


----------

We must brainstorm this one. Critical table is very important, but I think the community can really help us improve it. It's been like 2 goddamn years.

Post everything you DON'T like. But please keep in mind aimed shots vs fast shot.

Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 22, 2015, 04:20:11 am
Man of Steel: You don't get protection from being juggled by grenade launchers/rockets, but you have a great protection vs aimed shot knockouts, being crippled, etc.

Stonewall: You run a greatly increased risk of being knocked out, but avoid the bullshit from autoknockdown weapons.


This is basically the tradeoff we are proposing. By calculation if you are facing a sniper with RBTE and better crits against Man of steel it will be a max roll of (100+20(BC))-(15MOS+(10(armor crit resist)-5(RBTE Negating 50% crit resist). So MOS will counter better crit preventing an attacker to roll 101+ unless he is using a +5crit power weapon.

This is why RBTE need a change too to go with this. It will also end this sniper tank that have been abused for too long.

MOS will be then the counter of better crits as it shouldve been.


First of all I'd like to mention that making perks that put weapon crits at a stable and reliable experience is a bad idea. This encourages people to make builds that can only fight other builds. And right there - you break balance.

Currently there is no balance because stonewall halves the chances of being knocked out. Like I said previously MOS will prevent the heavier roll but it still possible to achieve it with +5 crit power weapon. Wich can of course be counter by a -5 crit power helmet.

If you look at the crit table we are proposing, MOS will not prevent the 91-100 roll to happen meaning you can still be bypassed if successful LK roll for the attacker AND Knocked Out if The roll again is successful so mostly 50% chance assuming every pvp char have 10EN.

Keep in mind acosta that we have think about it and we know that Tanks cannot have more than 5LK Fully implanted so your chance of bypassing is still correct in the eyes (50% at LK5).


Toughness and Even Tougher should be basic generic perks at low level. It helps you progress and you'll need it for combat.

If we manage to find a solution to fix this critical table and agree an a solid base then we will talk about this dont worry we already have a lot of ideas about toughness but it will be after this.

Critical table should be more progressive
Eye shots/ etc
1.5x minimum
2x
2.5x
3x
3.5

I made this with the help of a player who played sniper build since a very long time and that would be a too big change for snipers considering the actual stackable DR. Problem is that Normal DR is too high and sniper weapons have a too wide damage range when energy weapon hit too hard du to low armor energy resist.
That will be also the subject of another post already discussed with various people and i can say we all agree on a lot of things about this.
Again this will come in time.
First crit table.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: vig on April 22, 2015, 02:57:29 pm
First off, I like many of the suggested changes to the crit table from the original poster. However, there are some minor issues with it. I will propose an edited version of the suggested crit table and explain some of the minor changes that I have decided to make to it further down:

*
I think addressing KO's before nerfing them out of the crit table is in order before the rest.
So the main issue with the KO's is that they just steal too much of your valuable AP in a high-octane fast paced RT battle and they feel undeserved because the shooter just got lucky and laid you out. Essentially, if you get knocked out in the heat of the battle you might as well consider yourself dead and there is nothing that you can do to influence getting out of the prone state once you are in it. Perhaps reducing the AP cost of getting knocked out is in order? I'm not entirely certain what the current ko ap cost is, but it seems like it's just way too much for the pace of the game. So I'd suggest reducing the current cost by 25-50% straight up.

**
In the suggested new crit table you get rewarded for rolling low 0-20. That means that as long as you crit, you can incur a status effect regardless of how bad your roll is and that is unacceptable. 0-20 is meant to represent your crit power roll being SHIT and that is what you should get for rolling it. Otherwise there is absolutely no real downside, only consistent upside, which is not the way critical hits were meant to work in the first place. How were they meant to work? Like a gamble. You take a gamble and hope to do well. Just take a look at the original crit table's weakest power rolls. You can't take the randomness aspect out of the critical hits because it is not difficult to incur a critical hit with a focused build.
So what does it all mean then and what should be done. Nothing extravagant, essentially the 0-20 power rolls should remain as they originally were. Think of it as you rolling a crit power roll of -120 and the bad effect is that your attack doesn't really do much except for increased damage-> you don't get what you want and what you want is to incur a devastating status effect. Be grateful that crit roll 0 doesn't just blow you up.
bottom line, maintain the shittiness of 0-20 power rolls as a contrast to the awesomeness of 120 rolls.

The Suggested crit table by Original Poster for reference
(http://s12.postimg.org/tqd1lru99/reloaded_test2.jpg)

edited version:
(http://i.imgur.com/zHNkkke.png)

***
Regarding Toughness, Even Tougher, Stonewall, Quick Recovery and Man of Steel and other perks: they should be addressed after the table is discussed; appropriate changes can be made to the perks afterwards.
[Toughness] could be Normal DR +10% Normal DT+1(yes, 1, not 2. Currently, Toughness seems to work as Even Tougher's retarded brother)
[Even Tougher] Normal DR +5% Normal DT+3
sum total of them both combined being 15%DR and 4DT

Why so? DR is very good against critical hits, DT is great against bursts, so [Even Tougher] focuses on burst protection, [Toughness] on single powerful shots/crit protection.


Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 22, 2015, 05:45:21 pm
Your ideas are interesting vig.
Concerning the KO duration it is mainly because on the current crit table you get a KD + a KO so you have AP reduction of a KO + a KD.
So for the roll in the groin 71-90 we came up with the idea of giving it a KO chance instead of auto KD+ roll KO. I think the KO chance is enough for groin.
The problem at the moment is that for a sniper its either score a KO or be dead. This is the main problem.
I like the changes youve made thoughbut the groin I'd rather keep a low KO chance rather than a KD+ KO roll like it was before.
I also agree with the lowest rolls it can be changed


I like the idea of reducing AP cost of KO too. But the damage between small guns and plasma for example is too high. Small guns need a buff, by reducing the gap between min max damage and make it more stable.
I want to wait before talking about that but a lot of things need to changed.

For toughnesses we had ideas of simply removing the DT bonus but it depends on what will happen with implants because bursters might get too powerfull.
If we change snipers we need to change tanks as well but sniper more than anyone need those precious AP, so a change in drugs is to keep in mind too.

More feedback please!
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: vig on April 22, 2015, 06:46:37 pm
Concerning the KO duration it is mainly because on the current crit table you get a KD + a KO so you have AP reduction of a KO + a KD.
So for the roll in the groin 71-90 we came up with the idea of giving it a KO chance instead of auto KD+ roll KO. I think the KO chance is enough for groin.
The problem at the moment is that for a sniper its either score a KO or be dead. This is the main problem.
I like the changes youve made thoughbut the groin I'd rather keep a low KO chance rather than a KD+ KO roll like it was before.

If you look at the groin KO else KD part, "else" means that if you don't get a successful Knock Out (it's not likely), then you do not miss out on knocking down. As in if you don't get a knock out on a mid-powerful groin crit, you still get a chance to knock down if knock out fails. But if knock out succeeds, then there is no knockdown.


Quote
I like the idea of reducing AP cost of KO too. But the damage between small guns and plasma for example is too high. Small guns need a buff, by reducing the gap between min max damage and make it more stable.
I want to wait before talking about that but a lot of things need to changed.

I think an ammo and weapon rebalance thread is in order as well. For example I was thinking that .223 ammo should get the penetrate perk but have less %DR than it has now. Some ammo is unusable in pvp nowadays, like the 7.62mm in m60 and fnfal. Actually, most ammo that doesn't have penetrate is near unusable in pvp. This all can be addressed either by changing the resistance giving perks or looking at the ammo/weapons individually and looking at their damage output on the field.

Quote
For toughnesses we had ideas of simply removing the DT bonus but it depends on what will happen with implants because bursters might get too powerfull.
If we change snipers we need to change tanks as well but sniper more than anyone need those precious AP, so a change in drugs is to keep in mind too.

The vast majority of weapons in the game are Normal damage based and near-useless against Normal DR%/DT focused builds. They do not have penetrate weapon perks nor penetrating ammo. They do not have alternative damage type ammo or they do too little damage to make any significant impact. There needs to be a standard for determining whether a weapon is good enough or not. Something along the lines of taking out someone in CAMK2 with high hp but no DR% perks in a certain amount of time.
Do small guns need a buff? Not all of them, maybe not even most of them. High plasma damage doesn't mean anything, since decent armour has decent plasma res on it. Yes, by itself, looking at the numbers on weapons only shows that plasma weapons are really powerful, but then you take a look at plasma ammo (MFC) and what do you see? Nothing impressive: plasma ammo has no armour penetration nor damage modifiers, while some commonly used pvp normal type ammo has -DR% and penetrate perks on them. Looking at the bigger picture, plasma and laser weapons get weakened significantly by every point of resistance the target has, whereas a gun with DT splitting perks and decent damage doesn't suffer from minor increases in the opponent's resistance. Everything is relative in this case. So it's as I said, there needs to be a standard amount of HP that needs to be reduced to -20 in a specific number of APs in a certain amount of time.

Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 23, 2015, 06:15:47 pm
5 years playing a sniper here, though very little experience playing tankers (so I don't remmeber epic KO's, only 6 HP critical hits).

Two things immediately come to mind. KO AND KD is a bit much. I also think it should only be one or the other, never both.

Secondly Quick Recovery has barely been mentioned, as a level 3 perk with low requirements I think it should definitely be considered as part of the discussion as other perks are. For a long time the perk wasn't working properly, but I don't know if/when it was fixed.

I'll revisit the thread after work when I have time and a real computer instead of an iPotato at my disposal.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Corosive on April 23, 2015, 06:57:59 pm
BUMP
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 26, 2015, 06:00:47 am

If you look at the groin KO else KD part, "else" means that if you don't get a successful Knock Out (it's not likely), then you do not miss out on knocking down.

Thats a good idea but i dont know if thats achievable to be honest need a dev advice here im afraid.
We tried to make it simple at maximum.

Concerning the changes youve made i dont see any objection for the moment looks good so far.


I think an ammo and weapon rebalance thread is in order as well.

Kilgore has already something in mind apparently dont know what it is tho. But a rebalance of weapon and ammo would be huge so if he already did something no need for this. Would be great to see it tho but eh...


Yes, by itself, looking at the numbers on weapons only shows that plasma weapons are really powerful, but then you take a look at plasma ammo (MFC) and what do you see? Nothing impressive: plasma ammo has no armour penetration nor damage modifiers

Plasma weapon are single shot weapon so it means its used for aimed shots.
So were talking about crit table here where damage in head in multiplied by 3 and groin by 2.5 thats why the ammo got no DR mod it would be too powerful.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: eight8 on April 26, 2015, 09:03:15 am
ideas people who play only with crt brusters withot stone wall and have str1... y make game only 4 u... i play with normal tank and dont have problems with kos. i have ew sniper and only with very good turbo plasma take high dm and ko people. my english is shit so i will say in pl and u can translate... przy tego typu zmianach sniper i sniper cripler build przestanie istniec w tej grze. stone wall perk i sily 8 jest wystarczajaca obrona przed pancorem. ko snipera jest minimalne jezeli sie nauczysz poruszac (patrzec w lewo lub w prawo gdy strzela w oczy. gdy w reke lewa adwroc postac w lewo gdy w prawa odwroc postac w prawo. gdy w groin odwroc pstac tylem. z nogami tak jak z rekoma.) jezeli ludzie zaczna grac tylko jedna swoja postacia(co jest wysoce prawdopodobne po resecie) bd grac tankami i znowu bd problem i placz a crit bruister bd dominowal w grze bo przed krytycznymi obrazeniami z brusta nic nie zrobisz kazdy bd padal po 2 brustach takej postaci ... moim zdaniem lepiej bd dodac do helmow czy pancerzy dodatkowe odpornosci na ko. porobic komplety uzbrojenia ktore by dawaly dodatkowe bonusy np. perk stone wall (uzywane razem) gra bd trudniejsza... a nie tylko te same placzace posty...
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Mad Matt on April 26, 2015, 12:13:27 pm
ideas people who play only with crt brusters withot stone wall and have str1... y make game only 4 u... i play with normal tank and dont have problems with kos. i have ew sniper and only with very good turbo plasma take high dm and ko people. my english is shit so i will say in pl and u can translate... przy tego typu zmianach sniper i sniper cripler build przestanie istniec w tej grze. stone wall perk i sily 8 jest wystarczajaca obrona przed pancorem. ko snipera jest minimalne jezeli sie nauczysz poruszac (patrzec w lewo lub w prawo gdy strzela w oczy. gdy w reke lewa adwroc postac w lewo gdy w prawa odwroc postac w prawo. gdy w groin odwroc pstac tylem. z nogami tak jak z rekoma.) jezeli ludzie zaczna grac tylko jedna swoja postacia(co jest wysoce prawdopodobne po resecie) bd grac tankami i znowu bd problem i placz a crit bruister bd dominowal w grze bo przed krytycznymi obrazeniami z brusta nic nie zrobisz kazdy bd padal po 2 brustach takej postaci ... moim zdaniem lepiej bd dodac do helmow czy pancerzy dodatkowe odpornosci na ko. porobic komplety uzbrojenia ktore by dawaly dodatkowe bonusy np. perk stone wall (uzywane razem) gra bd trudniejsza... a nie tylko te same placzace posty...

With this kind of changes, Sniper and Sniper-Crippler Builds will vanish from game. Stone Wall Perk with 8 ST is enough to to defend yourself against Pancor.
Sniper's KO is lowered to minimum if you learn how to move in-game.
(If someone is shooting your eyes, turn left or right. If someone try to cripple your right hand, turn right, if left turn left. When your groin is an enemy target, turn back. With legs problem is solved as with hands (read above)).
If people start to play only with one character (what is highly probable after the reset), they will start to play with tanks and the problem will be back, and players gonna start to cry again. Crit. Burster will dominate/prevail in-game cause you can not do anything about it. Everyone will fall down after two bursts of such a character....In my opinion the better idea, will be adding to armors and helmets additional bonuses, such as for example: Stonewall (used together with Level perk). Game will be harder.
...but not only cryfest posts...
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Beer on April 26, 2015, 07:35:42 pm
Thank you for the translation matt. The new crit table will actually be better for Cripplers because there are more effects all around the table. The only thing that will be needed is sitting there shooting and get crazy bypass ko or doing nothing at all. Nobody shoots for legs and only Cripplers shoot for arms. Most snipers shoot eyes and groin. And if you think it is so easy to spin your character all around in the middle of a fight... Maybe you should try it because I've never seen you or anyone do it before. This will also nerf crit burst ko so its isn't a buff to crit bursters. If crit burster was as effective as you say then maybe people would play them, but almost nobody does. And naturally new crit table means changes to other things such as perks for game balance.  As for them dominating the game and being able to do nothing about it, you mean that's not how it is right now with only snipers and stonewall tanks? And cryfest posts? Nobody is crying. Just trying to improve crit table.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Mad Matt on April 26, 2015, 07:49:47 pm
No problem, I'm curious how it end. Crit.table depend on real (no in-game one ) luck too much. You have one shot kills or nothing, nothing really between. In my opinion it sucks a little bit. But I try more to listen than speak cause Im PvE with TB orientation and not long ago just started some RT and PvP...I hope our guys from Dev.team will find some way out.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: eight8 on April 27, 2015, 01:59:11 pm
Beer u never see me like i play... but i play like that. and i dont have problems with ko when snipers shoot me (snipers with builds like melt, seki, zinthos...)u can found movis on you tube. i see u dont know how to make siper cripler... in this nerfed crit table when sniper crip will shot, enemy will drop wepon(this is not cripler when enemy dont have cripled arm or legg) when all critical table will be nerfed u all will cry on forum " omg tank with power armor omg its imposible to kill him. lets nerf tanks." like i say problem is not a critical table. i will live this post... u speak about shit not abou toilet.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Mighty on April 27, 2015, 02:22:44 pm
I agree with eight8

Snipers useless shit against good tanks
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 27, 2015, 10:38:02 pm
Tanks are supposed to be a counter to sniper very high KO chance.
With this version snipers are only KO bypass relying on pure luck not skill or anything. Thats not how you are supposed to play a sniper.

Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: favorite on April 28, 2015, 12:05:37 am
The whole point is turbo
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: KestreL on April 28, 2015, 01:51:44 am
Tanks are supposed to be a counter to sniper very high KO chance.
With this version snipers are only KO bypass relying on pure luck not skill or anything. Thats not how you are supposed to play a sniper.

Kinda offtopic but I feel the need to respond to this.

Tanks work like this: Rush enemy and shoot and tank untle you are dead.
Snipers work like this: Stay alive and score as many shots as possible untle you are dead. If you let a sniper shoot you 30 times in the period of 1 fight ofcourse he will get "lucky"
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 28, 2015, 02:45:13 am
Tanks are supposed to be a counter to sniper very high KO chance.
With this version snipers are only KO bypass relying on pure luck not skill or anything. Thats not how you are supposed to play a sniper.

How are we "supposed" to play a sniper?

How do you play on YOUR sniper?

After giving it some thought over the past couple of days I've come to the conclusion that it doesn't really matter what or how we change the crit table.  There are too many other factors that affect the balance, and it's impossible to make the majority happy.  When it comes to discussion on this topic you generally have two sides, and both have a golden calf on either end of the rifle that they don't want slaughtered regardless of how they present their arguments.

So, here are my thoughts.


According to this: http://forum.fonline-reloaded.net/index.php?topic=339.0

It seems it was intended that using Doc on KO players should revive them, but is bugged according to changelog edit.  I suggest fixing that and seeing how that changes the balance, I saw nowhere else where it was working properly as of now.

I had one tank this session that I used in Reno on occasion, and never experienced horrific AP draining KO's like I did on other characters.  It has Quick Recovery perk, and I noticed a significant difference both in testing and actual use in pvp. 

Those two items alone should be enough to help safeguard against 30 AP KO/KD (and I still think it should be one or the other, not both).

Turbo Plasma is already being addressed as well...


As far as modifying the critical table, bonus rolls on specific weapons, and other examples - if you go through the changelogs from the start of this last session you'll see where the crit table was changed multiple times, bonuses and perks added, modified, and removed again from *certain* weapons.  It's been changed again, and again through the entirety of the last session.  I assume the changes were made using feedback from players, and not on a whim.  It's apparently still not right.

I'm all for giving aimed shot characters consistent damage that bursters and tanks dish out, with a little more damage and a critical effect on higher rolls, but I know people would cry and scream if that were the case. 

So without pointing fingers (because I don't need to) I suggest anyone who hasn't actually played a pure sniper build to actually give a shot this go around and see if their opinion changes.


http://forum.fonline-reloaded.net/index.php?topic=7226.msg55988#new
Re: Ban the Cookie Monster?
« Reply #28 on: April 15, 2015, 09:20:47 PM »

"I don't want a crit table from someone who doesn't play aimed characters at all."


I kind of agree with Kilgore on this one.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 28, 2015, 06:35:28 am
I made this with the help of a player who played sniper build since a very long time.

We try to make a better crit table thats all.

We didnt change that much comparing it to the old crit table. We removed KD +KO at the same time, removed KO from burst as well.

The auto-bypass were removed as well and check luck wich is always low when you play tank. The defender should always have a chance to escape most nasty effect depending on his special.

I believe the chance to cause a bypass or a KO are reasonable and are a compromise for both sides.

Remember that the game is supposed to be fun to play, a game (build) depending on luck (and I played sniper for your information), is not good and annoying for both sides.

I dont know whats your problem because when youre on the other side of a sniper gun and you experience this:

Spoiler: show
18:08:28 • You were critically hit in the right arm for 114 hit points, crippled your right arm, had your armor bypassed and had your weapon dropped.
18:08:32 • You were critically hit in the right arm for 105 hit points, crippled your right arm, had your armor bypassed and had your weapon dropped.
18:08:34 • Hit Points +150
18:08:38 • You gained 80 Current Hit Points.
18:08:48 • You heal the crippled right arm.
18:08:48 • You have gained 50 experience points.
18:10:01 • You were critically hit in the head for 49 hit points.
18:10:10 • Hit Points +49
18:10:55 • You were critically hit in the eyes for 60 hit points and blinded.
18:10:56 • You were critically hit in the eyes for 55 hit points.
18:10:59 • You gained 80 Current Hit Points.
18:10:59 • You were critically hit in the right arm for 102 hit points, crippled your right arm, had your armor bypassed and had your weapon dropped.
18:11:02 • You were critically hit in the head for 112 hit points, knocked out and had your armor bypassed.
18:11:06 • You were critically hit in the head for 55 hit points and knocked out.
18:11:17 • You were hit for 38 hit points.
18:11:21 • You were hit for 52 hit points and were killed.


I think youre able to talk about the crit table as well.

And cryfest posts? Nobody is crying. Just trying to improve crit table.

ANd this is what we are trying to do so look at what we propose tell us what you think is wrong about it. If youre here to start forum pvp do it elsewhere.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: KestreL on April 28, 2015, 06:46:05 am
AP regen in this server is so slow, so getting up from KO is very unlikely. Removing KD + KO would be a step, but not the whole way.

I would also like to suggest to disallow the ability of KO'ing someone who is already knocked out. That is just unrealistic.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: S.T.A.L.K.E.R on April 28, 2015, 07:14:50 am
AP regen in this server is so slow, so getting up from KO is very unlikely. Removing KD + KO would be a step, but not the whole way.

I would also like to suggest to disallow the ability of KO'ing someone who is already knocked out. That is just unrealistic.
aahahaah bringing realism to a game Hahahahaha

Also ya that is a very good idea though, its just stupid how it is ingame atm.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Mighty on April 28, 2015, 10:29:53 am

Spoiler: show
18:08:28 • You were critically hit in the right arm for 114 hit points, crippled your right arm, had your armor bypassed and had your weapon dropped.
18:08:32 • You were critically hit in the right arm for 105 hit points, crippled your right arm, had your armor bypassed and had your weapon dropped.


It is Gauss Rifle, TPR, Bozar ?
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 28, 2015, 10:38:47 am
It is Gauss Rifle, TPR, Bozar ?

.223 pistol
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Adams on April 28, 2015, 11:02:33 am
:D
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Mighty on April 28, 2015, 11:25:20 am
It is Gauss Rifle, TPR, Bozar ?

.223 pistol
1 St ?
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Troll on April 28, 2015, 11:31:57 am
It is Gauss Rifle, TPR, Bozar ?

Gauss rifle minimum bypass damage is 135, 183 on average.
Bozar minimum bypass damage is 150, 179 on average.
TPR minimum bypass damage is 150, 195 on average.
.223 pistol MAXIMUM bypass damage is 140.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Johnny on April 28, 2015, 11:34:45 am

1 St ?

St doesnt matter for bypass can we stop off topic
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 28, 2015, 02:39:02 pm
Don't recall your sniper build.

Point stands, table has been changed repeatedly, people are still not happy. When we get the changelog this week we'll see what changes have been made, and we'll see what PvP balance looks like in the next few weeks.

I see some of my other points were ignored as well, specifically quick recovery and using Doc to heal KO.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Troll on April 28, 2015, 03:23:18 pm
General gameplay will be more balanced, like at session start, but crit table will still feel a bit like : nothing, scratch, scratch, nothing, wrecked...
It's that feeling we wanted to remove with this new crit table. In old one, you have nothing or all effects combined more or less. With new one you can have one, then another, and sometimes both, because each has a roll, and no non rolled effects that stack. Special will be more important in order to resist critical effects, especially perception and luck. So snipers will have much lower bypass and blinded chance, but they lack of tankyness anyway, tanks will have higher blinded and bypass chance, but lower weapon drop, cripple and KD, and even lower KO is they take bonehead and man of steel.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 28, 2015, 05:48:58 pm
I understand the crit table, but I re-read the thread and am unclear on how RBtE is proposed to change.

Implementing this crit table as suggested may reduce 30 AP KO/KD, but it's going to get snipers nerfed yet again on the change following this one... because people will cry about this.

 :(

I honestly think that small changes need to be made incrementally, large re-works always tend to create more problems than they solve once it's actually put to a test.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Troll on April 28, 2015, 09:11:16 pm
Read it again, and make some calculations. Blinding is a bit easyer, as is weapon drop. KO and armor bypass are not as likelly, or depends much more on target special.
RBTE reduce 50% of crit CHANCE modifier from helmets.
The idee here is to add a -50% crit POWER also, to make it a must have for snipers.
Was Johnny gave you here is a "super balance fix pack", you need all the elements for it to work properly.
We planned that neew table regarding that perks would also change, making them better/compensate, a bonehead+mos tank is almost impossible to KO, but if sniper has RBTE he still has a chance, if he don't he simply can't, and thats one exemple. Read the table again.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 28, 2015, 09:38:19 pm
I assure you I understand it from reading it and re-reading it, it's simply that I feel that additional critical effects even on the lowest rolls won't go over well with everyone. It will cause hurt feels and anger, and we will just have this discussion again next year as a result. Just my opinion.

Fuck it, change it right now, we'll test it. I could be wrong. It needs tested though.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Troll on April 29, 2015, 02:26:54 am
OFC it needs testing. I made some calculations, on average TC build, blinded is like 10% more likelly to occur, around same number for weapon drop. KO chance has been decreased, as KO duration. But nothing is worth some old fashionned beta testing.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 29, 2015, 10:24:17 am
But nothing is worth some old fashionned beta testing.

That's actually what I've been working on the past several hours.  I fired up the 2238 SDK and made the recommended changes to RBtE, MOS, and Stonewall in combat.fos and moved onto the crit table itself.  I was planning on running both the current table and the suggested table for comparisons.

However the first thing I noticed is that the Critable Tool itself doesn't support the new suggested table, or at least doesn't appear to.  For each targeted body part and roll ( 0-5 ) the tool only seems to allow one test stat to roll against, which is how the current crit table is.  Only one test stat appears per target/roll.

The suggested table has at least two different stats being tested, and in some cases three.  It may very well be possible to manually code it in and roll against several stats at once, but someone who understands Codeine better then me would have to answer that one. 

Some clarification on that might be nice...
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Troll on April 29, 2015, 11:06:49 am
That's a shame, I hope that it will be possible to roll mutiple stats for each crit, because that's what makes the new table interesting. However, if it's truly impossible, we'll have to think the table with a single roll per crit. But maybe mojuk can do something. He seems good with combat code manipulation.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on April 29, 2015, 08:26:47 pm
That's a shame, I hope that it will be possible to roll mutiple stats for each crit, because that's what makes the new table interesting. However, if it's truly impossible, we'll have to think the table with a single roll per crit. But maybe mojuk can do something. He seems good with combat code manipulation.

I was hopped up on energy drinks at 5am, so it's very possible I overlooked something. I'll have to poke around more.

Hearing from mojuk would be nice (at some point, I'm guessing he's busy this week).
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Beer on May 30, 2015, 02:15:48 pm
So is this idea dead? I'd like to see this receive consideration
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Troll on May 31, 2015, 12:26:14 am
So do I.
But without implants things feel more balanced, so they don't come here anymore.
We still don't know if it's possible to make multiple rolls for SPECIAL check.
Even with more average damage and more KD, we still have that "nothing-nothing-PWNED" feeling. But stonewall rework made things already better.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: mojuk on May 31, 2015, 08:54:41 am
We still don't know if it's possible to make multiple rolls for SPECIAL check.
Sorry, forgot about this one.
With current crit table it's not possible to make multiple stat rolls for 1 crit roll. It's not impossible to add second roll but it's not 5min job to add it, not to mention testing it properly. So I would say possible but not any time soon because there are other things to finish first.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Wind_Drift on June 01, 2015, 10:12:04 pm
We still don't know if it's possible to make multiple rolls for SPECIAL check.
Sorry, forgot about this one.
With current crit table it's not possible to make multiple stat rolls for 1 crit roll. It's not impossible to add second roll but it's not 5min job to add it, not to mention testing it properly. So I would say possible but not any time soon because there are other things to finish first.

Thanks for answer.
Title: Re: Suggestion about crit table
Post by: Admiral Zombie on June 02, 2015, 12:57:49 am
We still don't know if it's possible to make multiple rolls for SPECIAL check.
Sorry, forgot about this one.
With current crit table it's not possible to make multiple stat rolls for 1 crit roll. It's not impossible to add second roll but it's not 5min job to add it, not to mention testing it properly. So I would say possible but not any time soon because there are other things to finish first.

I always feel like 1/2 of all suggestions can be eliminated merely by coding/engine limitations of some kind.